While trying to decide what blog(s) I was wanting to follow this term in ECI 832, I came across a post on the “Cool Cat Teacher” blog on making a case for cell phone use in class. This caught my attention immediately, because I am always expressing my wish for students to have access to cell phones and I-pods in the classroom. School division and school policies prevent this from happening right now, and I am not expected that to change any time soon.
My first thought was… wait a minute… maybe if I was able to start giving other teachers in my school and school division some concrete ideas as to how they might use these tools in their classroom, then maybe… just maybe…more teachers would start to make requests and eventually we would be able to chip away at the policy mountain.
I believe that it is basic fear that keeps us from allowing the “evil” cell phone in our classrooms. How would we ever control what they are doing? How could we ever keep their attention? How can we prevent them from texting when they should be listening?
The same goes for the i-pod. What could they possibly do with the i-pod in the classroom besides plug in and tune me out? Don’t get me wrong… I was one of these fearful teachers not so many years ago. When cell phone use first started to become popular and we were not sure what to do about it, I was all over making policies with specific and controlling consequences for being caught with your cell phone. I’ve come a long way baby!
Fear of giving up control can keep teachers from opening up to new and very exciting possibilities.
In her post Vicki Davis gives 10 reasons why we should use cell phones in school, many of them great reasons to use in conversations with school division policy makers. What school division does not like an idea that could actually save them money and solve some IT problems as well? She also has some suggestions as to how to “deal” with cell phones in the classroom.
The second reason I think we are reluctant just to give up our fight is because it opens up supervision and education issues that we are unsure of. How can we make sure they are on task and doing what they are supposed to be doing? So, does it come back to giving up control?
My search led me to blog site, “Technology for Teachers” by Sean Martinson. He said … the cell phone (iPods, MP3 players, etc.) are simply the latest tools that we as educators are failing to embrace, failing to see the educational implications for their uses, and are thus failing to educate our students in the ethical uses of these tools for life long learning. If we are going to ban said items… we are banning them because we as educators are failing to educate our students in the proper uses of these tools.” Sean give many great sources to check out in his post.
I listened to a conversation related to this issue in my school last week. The French Club is raising money to attend the Festival du Voyageur in Winnipeg, Manitoba. One of the fundraising ideas they came up with was to have a cell phone or i-pod day and everyone who chooses to bring one has to pay $1. Reaction from the staff was mixed. I said, “Yes!”, perhaps we could get them to do something educational at the same time?? Unfortunately, most of the reactions were based on comments such as:”do we get to set our own rules as to when they can use them?” or “won’t they be fooling around with them instead of learning?”
I hated the fact that it was seen as a policing issue rather than an opportunity. I have some work to do and educating teachers is how I think it needs to be done. I could slide in ideas and they wouldn’t even know what I was up to. Please give my any ideas that you may have.
Some other excellent sources I came across, that you may want to check out are:
I was watching my 11 year old son doing his homework the other night. He was working on an assignment that went along with a story they were reading in ELA. He needed to figure out what some of the vocabulary words meant. I was just going to open my mouth to tell him to get a dictionary out of the office, but before I could, he picked up his i-pod and was at dictionary.com.
It really is that simple, isn’t it?